skip to main content
A-Z Index Directory Calendar Libraries Webmail
826
We the People

"I've seen in these students an ability to speak on their feet and an ability to go beyond the surface of some really hard stuff. That is a skill that they can use just about anywhere."

Conversations About the Constitution A Spring Term course helps students grasp the separation of powers in the U.S. Constitution

Brian Murchison, the Charles S. Rowe Professor of Law, strode into the mock trial room in Lewis Hall. Dressed in a black robe befitting a judge, he took the bench and formally opened proceedings of the U.S. Supreme Court in the case of Morrison v. Olson.

Before him were Maggie Nolan '19 and Matt Mesisklis '19, to argue whether the Independent Counsel Act, which allowed for the investigation and prosecution of government officials for certain violations of federal criminal laws, violates the constitutional principal of separation of powers.

Murchison invited Mesisklis, counsel for the appellant, to present his case. As if he were before the real Supreme Court justices, Mesisklis laid out his argument. The Hon. Murchison pressed for details, explanations, clarifications. Back and forth the two went. Then Mesisklis summarized and relinquished the floor to Nolan, counsel for the respondent, who presented her side. Again, Murchison questioned specific points, called for elucidation and honed in on precise definitions.

At the close, Murchison praised the students for their performance. "You had a great command of the facts and your delivery was great. You committed your argument to memory and spoke directly to the bench in a conversational tone. You also began by offering the bench a road map of your argument so when you got to that point, I was ready."

The class is Separation of Powers in the U.S. Constitution, and this four-week Spring Term version represents a reconceptualization of the course Murchison teaches to law students. As well as in-depth readings and discussions, students prepare oral arguments of several landmark cases and play the role of attorneys arguing before the Supreme Court. With its podium and full bench for the judges, Murchison finds the mock trial room a valuable tool — "a place where college students can get a first stab at this kind of conversation."

Mesisklis, a politics and history major, spent about two hours preparing his argument, "looking over court cases about executive officers and identifying clauses in the Constitution which pertained to the case. I went through the argument in my head a few times, trying to predict what Maggie would say in response, and how I would rebut it."

He added, "The arguments are very challenging, and a lot of the cases are confusing, but it definitely pushes us out of our comfort zone, which is a great thing and fairly unique to a good liberal arts school."

The class focuses on the structural part of the Constitution, rather than the Bill of Rights, "which is the snazzy stuff," said Murchison. "I think it's a really interesting area. What I love about the students is that they are so dedicated to the learning process. They are very inspiring to me and have shown a great sensitivity to the notion of law as a complex and nuanced method of problem solving. When the class ends, I always want to head back to the library and work on the next day's class, because I feel that they are giving the class all they have and so should I."

Although the class holds great appeal for students interested in attending law school, it's not just for the pre-law set. "I've seen in these students an ability to speak on their feet and an ability to go beyond the surface of some really hard stuff," said Murchison. "That is a skill that they can use just about anywhere."

The first week covered the Federalist papers, with a close examination of Marbury v. Madison, the grandmother of all constitutional law cases. "We were not reading the abridged version," noted Murchison. "We were studying the unedited version, which is John Marshall taking on Thomas Jefferson — two Virginians who were so different and such antagonists. The students and I were swept away by the drama of the case and how Marshall eked out a triumph of sorts. Even though the case is from 1803, it is still a pretty contemporary-sounding fight over the separation of powers."

Students also read more recent court cases, and Murchison had them analyze two dissents by the late Justice Antonin Scalia. "Scalia — he's no shrinking violet," said Murchison. "We had some great discussions over the concept of originalism. Do we emphasize the original meaning of the Constitution or do we emphasize the contemporary meaning? Has there been a change? If so, what is it? If not, why not?"

He added, "I see my job as a guide. I'm helping them walk through the landscape more than telling them what to think. I want to point out the highlights. It's kind of like being on the Snake River on a raft with the guide saying, ‘OK, there might be a really great osprey 100 yards from here.' To be able to help them see a couple of ospreys or eagles, or appreciate the white foam in the water, is really kind of fun for me."

In addition to the intense in-classroom discussions, the students took a field trip to Madison's home in Montpelier for a tour, and discussed Madison's philosophy with an expert at the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution, also at Montpelier.

"I wanted them to get a sense of Madison and the fact that while he was in college he had studied democracy, in particular the Scottish Enlightenment," said Murchison. "I wanted them to drink in the Madison stuff, because they are as open and concerned and thoughtful as he was. You start with an open book and then you keep moving from that first piece of information and keep adding to it and keep talking, as he did. This is the way great things happen."

- Louise Uffelman | luffelma@wlu.edu

Photo: Matt Mesisklis '19 lays out his argument before Brian Murchison, the Charles S. Rowe Professor of Law, during a mock trial session of Morrison v. Olson.

Transformative Education

Washington and Lee seeks to foster an atmosphere of self-discovery and an environment where anything is possible.

In Action People and Programs

Washington and Lee fosters an atmosphere of self-discovery and an environment where anything is possible. From research theses to fully student-led theater productions, the University makes it easy for students to follow their dreams. Every year, students present research proposals to faculty and pursue hypotheses in both the sciences and the arts. Student research can occur both on campus and off, with research grants specifically designated for both areas.

With an average class size of 16, it's easy to find faculty advisors for both major projects and new clubs. Many students propose self-guided majors or pursue a double-or even triple-major, given the inclusive nature of a liberal arts education. This provides students with the opportunity to discover their passions, and also with the support to pursue them.

The University's four-week Spring Term is designed to be transformative. The courses offered during the term are set up with the dream-class concept in mind, remarkable examples of creative and expansive teaching: studying painting in Italy; the Freedom Rides throughout the South; the physics of music; code-breaking in mathematics and history; aerial dance; and many, many more. Rigorous internships and co-curricular programs like Mock Convention, the Venture Club and the Williams Investment Society immerse students in real-world learning situations that bring the concepts they've studied in the classroom to life.

Related Stories

At a Glance Facts and Figures

At W&L, 22% of classes have 2-9 students, 49% have 10-19 students, 27% have 20-29 students and just 1% has 30-39 students.
44 Johnson Scholarships are awarded annually.
114 Johnson Opportunity Grants have been awarded since 2009 to support student summer experiences.
The W&L course catalog includes 1200+ courses in 37 majors and 21 minors.
190 new courses were created by W&L faculty for the new four-week Spring Term.

Visit, Interview, Apply See Yourself Here

Ready to learn more? Come visit us in Lexington for a campus tour and class visit, or connect with one of our admissions counselors in a city near you. We look forward to meeting you.

Visit Tours and Interviews

Step One:

Schedule your visit with a campus tour and/or info session online.

Step Two:

Call our office to schedule your interview and/or class visit (for high school seniors only). We will coordinate your interview and class visit with your already scheduled visit. (540) 458-8710.

Can't make it to Lexington?

There are various ways in which you can still connect with Washington and Lee University and the Office of Admissions:

Apply Now

Apply Quick Guide

Deadlines:
  • Early Decision is a binding commitment; enrollment is required if you are accepted.
    • ED-1: Nov. 1
    • ED-2: Jan. 1
  • Regular Decision is for students who want to maximize options.
    • Deadline: Jan. 1
  • Johnson Scholarship (additional essay required, instructions on the W&L Writing Supplement to the Common Application.)
    • Deadline: Dec. 1
Testing:
Application Materials:

Financial Aid and Scholarships

We seek to ensure that the cost of attending W&L does not prevent outstanding students from choosing to enroll. A generous need-based aid program and merit-based scholarships can make that investment more manageable than you may think. Visit Financial Aid for more information.

The Johnson Scholarship Program awards over 40 full tuition, room and board scholarships annually. Read More

Admitted students who meet financial aid deadlines and are found to have need will have their full need met with grant funds and a work-study job -- no loans.

The W&L Promise guarantees free tuition to any undergraduate student admitted to Washington and Lee with a family income below $100,000. Learn More

Net Price Calculator

W&L

Washington and Lee University provides a liberal arts education that develops students' capacity to think freely, critically, and humanely and to conduct themselves with honor, integrity, and civility. Graduates will be prepared for life-long learning, personal achievement, responsible leadership, service to others, and engaged citizenship in a global and diverse society.